What is the aim of the exercise?
This session aims at familiarizing the participants with listening levels and skills and the power it can have. By exploring different types of listening and collectively brainstorming non-verbal and verbal aspects of active listening we prepare for a listening exercise that aims at making participants aware that their listening style and dedication has considerable effects on a conversation and their conversation partner.
In what context is this exercise useful?
This exercise is useful to support individuals and teams to understand the importance of listening skills and it can be connected as a preparation for the powerful questions exercise, once active listening is required for that exercise.
Preparation time: 20 min
Online / Onsite: Both
Workshop time: 1h 20 min
Ideal group size: 16/20 (groups of 4)
Equipment and tools needed:
Flip Chart if onsite or if online use slides/miro/google doc to:
expose model levels of listening
to collect brainstorm aspects of active listening
expose exercise instructions
Online or Onsite Room to run the session
Post-it’s & pens (if onsite)
Markers (if onsite)
Paper with listening instructions
Activity & Format
Time
Instructions
Facilitation Notes
Check-in and Session Introduction
10 min
Introduction of facilitators and participants if needed
Present today’s topic and agenda
Check-in on participants mood, expectations, or other. You can suggest a check-in question as “In one sentence, how are you arriving today?”
Start with answering the check-in question by yourself and then hand the word over to someone else, allowing everyone to share. Nice start for hearing all the voices in the room.
Topic introduction
10 min
Start creating the space for the reflections and conversations of today: you can ask the audience if they are paying attention to the ways they have been listening.
Then highlight that listening is a super underrated leadership skill. However, it is a super important skill, because the way we listen and pay attention in a conversation can profoundly shift the quality and depth of that conversation, and the quality of relationship we are able to build to one another.
By listening deeply and actively, we are able to connect and make sense of each other, it helps us gain a deeper understanding of different perspectives, allowing individuals and groups to connect to each other in a way that is more inclusive, open and respecting potential differences. Changing the way we listen changes the way we experience and build relationships.
Comment that improving our listening takes practice and that we will try that later, but first it is important to look at interesting inputs on listening levels before we collectively brainstorm what active listening is composed of.
- Explain the model:
The 1st Level of listening is called Downloading.
This first level of listening is characterized by when we listen from our habits, from what we already know. We are just reconfirming what we already know, nothing new can come to us, because we just stay in our bubble, not focused or interested on what other people have to say, but maybe more interested on what we will say next. So basically we “download” and project our assumptions into the present situation, hence we also listen to what we already know.The result of this kind of listening is that we only reconfirm our existing opinions and judgements. Now in some situations this can be a very helpful way of attending to the world outside. If we think for instance of an apple, we know from experience that it is a healthy and tasty item to eat, so it saves us time if we can use our previous assumptions about apples so that we don't need to reevaluate every single time if an apple is healthy or potentially poisonous. Nevertheless in human interaction this level of listening blocks us from understanding other perspectives and opening our mind to new possibilities, and makes dialogue and collaboration impossible.
The 2nd Level of listening is called Factual.
When listening from level two we are starting to open our mind.
We notice disconfirming information/data, what the other says start to penetrate our own bubble. We actually focus on what the other person says, that is, we start to pay attention to what is different from how we thought it is. This level of listening is embedded in our scientific paradigm, all good science teaches to pay attention to disconfirming data as it is the source of innovation. The main driver of this kind of listening is curiosity.
The 3rd Level of listening is called Empathic.
Empathic listening is where we start to see the world through another person's eyes. It is only from this level of listening that our center of attention starts to move “outside of us” or beyond what we know. When I engage in downloading, my center of attention is within me, not noticing what is going on outside. Level two is still centered within me, but I am starting to pay attention to what is going on outside and I notice the differences to what I assumed to be true from my own experience. At this level, we see situations through the eyes of others, turning to the other person’s point of view. When practicing empathic listening with an open heart, the center of attention is focused on the experience of the other person(s). In fact, this allows us to gather much more information about the situation than what we might think. When seeing a situation from another person's perspective and experience we may experience feelings and thoughts we would otherwise not have connected with. It is through experiencing those feelings and perspectives that a deeper connection can unfold as the other person will start to feel heard, understood and seen as who he/she is.
- The 4th Level of listening is called Generative.
This fourth level of listening is something we don’t usually experience on a daily basis in our interactions with others. The key difference here is that there is something happening with the center of attention. It is no longer located in one specific person, rather the center, or source, from where the listening happens has no specific perspective anymore. It is somewhat “between '' people. It is in these moments when something really new can emerge, as we let go of our own sense of Self and together engage in a conversation where we let come what we don’t yet know, together. It holds space for something new to be born, listening with openness to what is unknown and what wants to emerge. Here we open our will to be changed by the conversation. We start to see reality with fresh eyes, and welcome yet unknown aspects. In generative listening we connect with one another and with an emerging future potential.
Comment that great leaders are able to sense what type of listening is needed at the moment and can adjust the quality of listening to the situation.
Explain that this model helps us to gain an idea about how diverse and complex listening can be. Maybe in future conversations, you can gain the awareness about what type of listening you are engaging in at the moment and what type of listening would be appropriate.
You can raise these questions for people to reflect and comment to the group (if you have enough time): Do these match? In general, where do you spend most of your own listening time? Can you actively try to practice the appropriate type of listening? How does your conversation change by doing so?
Check the resources list below for learning more and prepare yourself to explain the Levels of Listening Model.
Make sure you have prepared the flipcharts if onsite and if online the slides/miro/google
doc to:
expose the model levels of listening
to collect brainstorm aspects of active listening
expose exercise instructions
Collective Brainstorm
10 min
Now you can move your audience to a second moment of the session.
First, we have talked about internal attitude towards listening and what type of listening we engage in, and now we will collect the external signs of active listening, these can be verbal or non-verbal.
Ask people to answer: What comes to your mind? What do we need to be mindful of while listening?
Gather their answers and add the ones below in case people don’t mention it:
Eye contact
Posture and body language
Facial Expression (eg. smile, frown, …)
Lack of distractions(eg. phones, fidgeting, …)
Physical setup (eg. side by side, across, walking, …)
To show verbal reinforcement (eg. hmm, ah, …)
Paraphrasing (summarizing what the person has said).
Asking clarification questions
Asking reflection questions that support the person to reflect further.
Ok now that we have this whole list of things that play into active listening, we will practice it with the next exercise.
Gather their answers (if onsite in a flipchart or if online, share your screen and use a document/slide/
miroboard).
Instructions Exercise
(5 min)
For this exercise I need you to all take your chair, get together in pairs and set your chairs up vis-a-vis each other. All the pairs should be positioned parallelly.
Now each of you will get 6 minutes to talk to your partner about an experience you had. This does not need to be deep or special, but it needs to be a topic that you can effortlessly talk about for 6 mins. Maybe a vacation, your last weekend, a hobby you have, or anything that you want.
The other person should try to listen actively and follow the instructions that I will have on this flipchart during the exercise. Remember that as we have just discussed there are many, especially non-verbal, aspects that play into active listening.
Ask if people understood the instructions or if they have any questions.
Check the next table below in the document for exercise options for an online session.
Exercise
15 min
Start the exercise.
For the first round the prompts (shown in your flipchart) for the listeners will be:
Listen actively (1min)
Think about your to-do list for next week (2 min)
Criticize what your partner is saying in your thoughts (2 min)
Listen actively (1 min)
After 6 minutes, ask the pairs to change the roles (the one talking, now listen and vice-versa).
For the second round the prompts (shown in your flipchart) for the listeners will be:
Listen actively (1 min)
Listen with pity (1 min)
Listen with love (2 min)
Listen impatiently (1 min)
Listen actively (1 min)
Check the next table below in the document for exercise options for an online session.
Reflection in Pairs
5 min
Now instruct the pairs to take 5 mins to reflect with each other about how the experience of listening (with and without attention) and the experience of talking to someone who shows or not attention was.
Check the next table below in the document for exercise options for an online session.
Group Debrief
15 min
- Gather participants back in a circle, and facilitate the discussion into the feelings/ sharing/ impressions of the participants.
- You can ask them how their sharing time was; how this exercise made them feel (both roles: listener and speaker), what stood out for them, what were the insights, what they have learned about themselves and about others.
- Don’t forget at the end to ask what were the key take-aways from the session.
Check-out
10 min
- Provide logistical info about the next planned workshop (if any) or any necessary announcement.
- Check-out question: For example, get each person to say what they are leaving with from this session.
- Thanking people for joining and closing the session.
You can provide a document or in your preferred way the opportunity for them to provide feedback from this session.
Make sure to prepare yourself beforehand by for example meditating and being ready to give all your attention & empathy to the session. Focus on the present moment, speak slowly and clearly, breathe a lot and smile.
Also try to make it personal and share with your audience your experiences and how listening helped you down the road!
Contact of Workshop Developer:
- Explain that you will show today “The”. This model is part of the Theory U process, developed by Otto Scharmer from the Presencing Institute at MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology). According to Otto Scharmer , “Listening is probably the most underrated leadership capacity today, but listening is really at the source of all great leadership. When we see leadership failures, and today we have many opportunities to see that, very often at the source of these failures is a lack of listening. A lack of connection to what is really going on in reality right now.
What is the aim of the exercise?
This exercise aims at raising awareness of the power that powerful questions can have. Sometimes the counterpart doesn’t need you to provide input or to relate to their story. Asking a powerful question can kick-start reflection in new, unexplored ways and thereby give space for new opportunities and ways of thinking. Participants practice vulnerability (by sharing a current challenge), active listening, open-mindedness, and asking powerful questions.
In what context is this exercise useful?
To support building better relationships. Whether you’re a manager leading a team, a parent raising a child, or a friend asked for advice, someone in the world might be looking to you to help guide them on a path. When this happens we jump into the role of a coach. Great coaches inquire: asking powerful questions to uncover what’s really important, then enable others to tap into their own knowledge and expertise. This exercise is especially useful after exploring active listening, as one can directly apply active listening skills to support you with the right questions.
Preparation time: 10 min
Online / Onsite: Both (check online option at the end of the document)
Workshop time: 1h 45 min
Ideal group size: 12/18 (groups of 6)
Equipment and tools needed:
Flipchart, Board or slides/miro/chat to expose examples of powerful questions.
Activity & Format
Time
Instructions
Facilitation Notes
Check-in and Session Introduction
10 min
Introduction of facilitators and participants if needed
Present today’s topic and agenda
Check-in on participants mood, expectations, or other. You can suggest a check-in question as “In one sentence, how are you arriving today?”
Start with answering the check-in question by yourself and then hand the word over to someone else, allowing everyone to share. Nice start for hearing all the voices in the room.
Topic introduction
10 min
- Start creating the space for the reflections and conversations of today: you can ask the audience if they are used to receiving or giving powerful questions.
Then highlight the importance of the concept of powerful questions: by asking powerful questions we support others to uncover what’s really important, enabling them to tap into their own knowledge and expertise. Making powerful questions indicates that we are deeply and actively listening, committed to the conversation as well as to the well-being of the person, and it helps create a powerful bond between people and to build trust.
Powerful questions are questions that do not aim at pointing the receiver of the question in a certain direction but are meant to be fairly open. They give the receiver of the question the possibility to explore new thoughts or possibilities and encourage new ways of thinking.
Powerful questions aim at opening up a possibly narrow mindset without being judgmental or indicative. Powerful questions are simple as they are usually a single question and not multiple questions combined with statements or stories.
Powerful questions are open-ended, and asked with genuine curiosity. The next time you feel compelled to quickly jump in with ideas and suggestions, first get truly curious. Ask questions without an attachment to the answer. This will help you uncover the real issue, and can also help someone develop her own insight.
Show some examples of powerful Questions. (Check the resources at the end of the document for more examples)
Build understanding.
What challenges are you facing?
What matters to you right now?
What opportunities are you seeing?
Set direction.
Ask these to shift focus from what’s wrong to what’s possible:
What is the best possible outcome?
What are you trying to achieve?
What do you want to happen next?
What does success look like?
How will you know if you’ve succeeded?
Shape options.
Ask these to generate ideas:
What have you tried?
What options do you have? How possible is each option?
What would you have to believe for this option to be right?
Define next actions.
Ask these to clarify what should happen next:
What data/information do you need to make a decision?
What action can you take now?
What are you taking away from this conversation, as a next step or new way of thinking?
What support do you need? Where will you get it?
Exercise Instructions
Part 1
5min
In this exercise you will get 4 mins to share one challenge you are currently facing (more to that in a bit) with another participant and receive 1-3 powerful questions from them. On the other side you will actively listen to the challenge of other participants and pose powerful questions.
While you are listening to somebody’s challenge:
Apply what you have learned about active listening before.
Take some time to think before asking the powerful questions.
Pose your questions without making a statement, without summarizing, without giving advice, without relating the challenge to your own life and telling a story, without drawing a conclusion.
While you are sharing your challenge:
Try to be open to new directions of thought.
Receive the questions without answering them.
Keep your notebook with you to note down the questions you receive, you can reflect on them after the workshop.
If there was no previous workshop about active listening before, help the audience to remember some important points of active listening.
Exercise
Instructions
Part 2
Think of Challenge
5 min
You will now have a few minutes to think of the challenge you will share later. This can be anything that is on your mind at the moment, anything that you have trouble with. As always you are very welcome to be vulnerable and share a personal challenge regarding yourself, your relationships, fears, or anything else that you are currently dealing with.
Nevertheless, it is also important to choose what challenge you are comfortable with sharing and how vulnerable you want to be.
Exercise
Instructions
Part 3
Formation of Groups
5 min
We will form groups of 6. Each group forms one big triangle of three people on the outside and a smaller triangle with three people on the inside like so:
The people on the inner triangle start to share their challenge with their counterpart (4 min). Then the people on the outer triangle think of and pose powerful questions (3 min).
After 7 mins the people on the outer triangle rotate to the next person and the process is repeated. Therefore, every participant shares their challenge three times and receives powerful questions from three different people. (counting 21 minutes).
After the three cycles, the inner and outer triangles switch. In this way the people who shared first can experience offering powerful questions now.
Ask if people understood the instructions or if they have any questions.
Exercise Powerful Questions
42min
- One cycle: 4 min sharing, 3 min thinking and posing powerful questions.
In total: 6 x cycle above.
For each of the two groups one facilitator keeps the time and reminds them when to stop sharing and when to rotate.
Individual Reflection
5 min
Gather participants back to the big group. Give them 5 min of individual reflection, to note down any immediate thoughts about the questions received, the questions you posed or simply to let it sink in the exercise.
Group
Debrief
15min
- Facilitate the discussion into the feelings/ sharing/ impressions of the participants.
- You can ask them how their sharing time was; how this exercise made them feel, what stood out for them, what were the insights, what they have learned about themselves and about others.
- Don’t forget at the end to ask what were the key take-aways from the session.
Check-out
10 min
- Provide logistical info about the next planned workshop (if any) or any necessary announcement.
- Check-out question: For example, get each person to say what they are leaving with from this session.
- Thanking people for joining and closing the session.
You can provide a document or in your preferred way the opportunity for them to provide feedback from this session.
Make sure to prepare yourself beforehand by for example meditating and being ready to give all your attention & empathy to the session. Focus on the present moment, speak slowly and clearly, breathe a lot and smile.
Also try to make it personal and share with your audience your experiences and how powerful questions helped you down the road!
Leadership dimensions: Servant, Authentic, Ethical and Socially Responsible
Contact of Workshop Developer:
Examples of powerful Questions: and
What is the aim of the exercise?
This exercise aims at exploring the concept of leadership and establishing some common reference points regarding what it is, and what it isn’t.
In what context is this exercise useful?
This exercise is useful as it creates a general understanding of what is leadership. This allows people to understand better what constitutes a responsible leader and can provide guidance on how to improve on certain leadership traits.
Preparation time: 10 min
Workshop time: 80 minutes
Ideal group size: 16-20 people (groups of 4)
Contact of Workshop Developer:
Equipment and tools needed:
Papers
Pens
Activity & Format
Time
Instructions
Facilitation Notes
Check-In...
5 min
Introduction of facilitators
Present agenda
If a small group, check-in on participants mood, expectations, or other.
Get people to ‘arrive’ in the space. This will be a highly introspective session and participants will need full presence. Ask them to get comfortable, turn off any distractions. Take 3 deep breaths.
Start with answering the check-in question by yourself and let everyone share and then hand the word over to someone else.
Individual reflection
3 min
Individually, take three minutes to write down all words that pop into your mind when you think about leadership. Anything and everything goes. Suspend judgement, just write whatever comes to mind. No good or bad answers.
Work in pairs
4 min
In pairs, run your individual list of words by each other, and try to define recurrent words/ associations/ trains of thought, as well as the words that are most different between the two of you. No good or bad answers.
Allow about a minute between team making to allow people to get together.
Work in groups of 4
10 min
In groups of four, discuss your lists of words built as pairs, and try to identify overlaps, common denominators, and the ‘outliers’. Try to discuss briefly what are the common themes, and the most specific occurrences. Look for most surprising words in comparison to your individual lists.
Ask two pairs to join together (will save time instead of making completely new teams)
Discuss together
10 min
Building on the previous outcomes, jointly discuss common themes and outliers. Contribute with background info (e.g., highlight group findings).
Discuss what is the most surprising word/ association/ Train of thought, and what idea it sparked in your understanding of leadership.
Get people to join in a circle (space allowing).
Open the discussion to everyone, allow people to speak freely.
Contribute some input and short reflection
5 min
Present the different leadership dimensions (see table bottom of page).
As you present get participants to think…
do they have some words in common with the ones presented?
Which ones do they think are most important?
BREAK
5 min
Individual work
15 min
Please identify at least 3 common traits across the leadership models.
Based on the common traits, identify one figure of each of the following:
An obvious leader
A less obvious leader in your life
Make the table at bottom of page available for viewing by participants (e.g., project it on a wall, share digitally)
Present to group
15 min
Please make a short presentation of your work to your colleagues, explaining the traits you focused on, and how your ‘leaders’ display those traits.
Anyone that feels comfortable can present.
If people hesitate, the facilitator should jump in to present.
Check-out
5 min
Debrief activity, ask them if they enjoyed it, gather quick feedback.
Provide logistical info about next planned workshop (if any)
Invite people to try the CARL leadership assessment. Once you get the results, CARL suggests readings and exercises to improve on the dimensions.
Check-out suggestion if small group: Get each person to say how they feel in one word after this workshop
Thank people for joining.
Please write us an email to leap@oikos-international.org with your tips for future facilitators. Please copy-paste this webpage URL in the email so we can easily update the page.
CARL website: https://carl2030.org/
CARL Leadership Assessment test: https://carl2030.org/survey/index.php
Servant
Leadership
Authentic
Leadership
Ethical
Leadership
Socially Responsible Leadership
Listening
Self-awareness
Justice
Self-understanding and Personal Integrity
Empathy
Lead with heart
Respect others
Healing
Focus on long-term results
Honesty
Taking seriously the perspective of others
Awareness
Integrity
Humane
Persuasion
Lead with vision
Focus on teambuilding
Contributing to a larger community
Conceptualization
Listening skills
Value driven decision-making
Foresight
Transparency
Encourages initiative
Knowledge and Intellectual Competence
Stewardship
Consistency
Leadership by example
Commitment to the Growth of People
Share success with the team
Values awareness
Striving for Excellence
Building Community
Drawing on experience
No tolerance for ethical violations